This will in fact not an issue with this framework; Sir John de- Keith d

Re: ? Comyn spouse from Malise

Regarding the Comyn daughter who had been spouse off Malise off Strathearn, I’d theorized for the 2005 you to definitely she had been Margaret, identified as wife regarding Sir John de- Keith (find backup out-of article less than) who had been 2ndly age are given in that article: the newest partner Emma I suggest try of another members of the family, and not mom of one’s second Earl Malise.

Scots Peerage, sub _Comyn, Earl regarding Buchan_ , says to some extent, ‘Malise, Earl away from Strathearn, got a wife Emma, from inside the 1261-1267, whose surname are unfamiliar ‘[SP II:256, alludes to Cal. off Docs., i. 2383, 2451]. a little while before 1270, so as that his widow (Margaret) might have been “available” a little while immediately after Emma.

This was of course a conjecture; it can feel the benefit of working with a known dating ranging from Muriel Keith and you can Reginald ce Cheyne. Any longer associated paperwork manage of course feel greet.

The account for the Scots Peerage regarding the group of Keith states out-of Sir John de- Keith (d. california. 1270) which he is actually said to have partnered Comyn, earl regarding Buchan . Which personality, of your not sure (“believed to was”) diversity, is now able to feel fixed according to the following the dispensation, old at Fondi for the fourteen Jan 1378/9::

‘ Reg Aven 215, fifty Towards the bishop of Moray. Faculty to help you distribute Reginald Cheyn, donzel, and you may Murielle, damselle, d de- Keth, from Moray and you can Aberdeen dioceses, on obstacle so you’re able to relationship as a result of the next and next degrees of consanguinity. Fondi, 19 Kal. Feb., anno step one. SRO Vat. Trans., iv, no. 46. ‘

Muriel Keith, the long term 2nd wife of Robert Stewart, very first Duke off Albany (d. 1420), is developed so you’re able to wed Reginald ce Cheyne, young man away from Sir Reginald ce Cheyne from the his partner (while the their very first partner), Helen out of Strathearn. When you’re you will find prominent gaps in the ancestry away from Muriel Keith, she and you can Reginald ce Cheyne create show a lineage regarding Comyns. Yet not, this is exactly as well faraway to require a dispensation if Muriel is an excellent-great-great grandd Comyn, Earl of Buchan (d. 1233), which could become case in the event the ‘s the reason daughter.

2. Reginald ce Cheyne is actually good-grandson from Marjory Comyn, child regarding Alexander Comyn, Earl regarding Buchan (d. 1290), young buck regarding William Comyn listed above. Her son is actually Malise, Earl regarding Strathearn off 1312 to his demise into the 1328 , and you will dad out of Reginald.

ca. 1270), was identical to Marjory Comyn, and you may married 2ndly to Malise, Earl away from Strathearn (d. 1312). This should mean brand new parentage Haitian kvinnlig a€?thought to has actually been’ compared to Margaret, partner out-of Sir John de- Keith, is out-of that age group: she’d not have already been this new d Comyn, Earl away from Buchan, but alternatively regarding their young man Alexander. There is absolutely no facts that Earl Malise and you will Marjory Comyn was indeed hitched much before 1275: as the Lindsay had written,

You will find you to discernable basis on what the partnership anywhere between Reginald le Cheyne and you will Muriel Keith might have existed: if Margaret Comyn, partner regarding Sir John de Keith (d

‘ New spouse associated with the earl, regarding 1275, is titled Marjory, once we see the attesting condition out of No. curriculum vitae., and that’s stated from the Wyntoun, Guide VIII. guy. vi., getting been the following cousin of John Comyn, Earl from Buchan, just who discussed for Earl Malise the marriage settlement a lot more than said [dated from the London area, April 26, 1293 to own their daughter Matilda and you can Robert de- Tony, child from Ralph].’

Alexander Comyn = Age de- Quincy Elizabeth regarding Buchan I __________________I________________ We III 1) Sir John = Marjory = 2) Malise de- Keith I (als I Age away from Strathearn . 1270 I Margaret) We d. 1312 _____________I__ ___I__________________________ I We We I We I Sir William Bernard Malise Gilbert Robert Maud de- Keith de- Keith Age regarding = Robert d. bef 1293 Strathearn; d. 1328 de Tony We ______I_______________________ I I We We Sir Edward Malise Mary Helen = Isabella de- Age from Strathearn = 1) Sir Reginald Synton d. california. 1343 We le Cheyne We We I = 2) Sir David We V I I de- Graham Sir William de- We We__________ Keith I I = Margaret Fraser __________________I_______ V __I_____________ I We I III I I We We Muriel + Reginald Mary Mariota Keith ce Cheyne (= Robert Stewart, Duke away from Albany)